A total of 17 cases with heavy precipitation occurred in NZ during the summer of 2011/2012 (Nov 2011 to Jan 2012) were selected for analysis in this paper. Synoptic analysis indicates that most of these events either resulted from an air mass developing in the Tasman Sea or are generated locally by the orographic impacts of South Alps, which means that these 17 cases have covered most common heavy precipitation generation mechanisms that occur during a NZ summer.
The results show that the accuracy of forecasts with the K-Nudging assimilation of observed reflectivity is improved on average for 6-9 hours ahead compared to the forecasts initialized using 3DVAR method and extrapolation (Cross-correlation) method. Furthermore, By assimilating extrapolated radar reflectivity with the K-Nudging, the results suggest that (1) the accuracy of forecasts largely depends on the accuracy of extrapolated reflectivity; (2) Generally, the accuracy of short term QPF could be further improved significantly by the assimilation of 1-3 h extrapolated radar reflectivity compared to the assimilation with observations only at the observation time.
However, all statistical scores show that, although radar observed/extrapolated reflectivity could be assimilated at the same resolution which the model is actually run, simple radar extrapolation scheme still should play an important role in 1-3 h precipitation nowcasting in operational applications.