A stratiform precipitation case on 8 December 2008 and that on 16 December 2008 were compared to describe differences of W, Vz, and LDR. Surface rainfall intensity was greater than 2 mm/h in the 16 December case, while raindrops evaporated until they reached to the ground in the 8 December case. Upward W above the melting level was greater than 0.2 m/s in the 16 December case, while it was weak (less than 0.1 m/s) or absent in the 8 December case. Vz of 1.6 m/s at 300 m above the 0 degC altitude (5.2 km MSL) in the 16 December case was greater than the 8 December case (1.3 m/s). The thickness of melting layer in the 16 December case (900 m) was greater than the 8 December case (300 m). Because Vz is an indicator of particle size, the results suggests that the size growth of hydrometeors under the presence of upward W contributed to the formation of thick melting layer in the 16 December case.
Owing to complex interfaces of water-coated ice crystal branches, LDR at the melting level increased 0.17- 0.20 in the two cases. Lidar dark band was also observed in the two cases. Vz of raindrops in the 16 December case (7.0-7.5 m/s) was greater than that in the 8 December case (3.7-3.9 m/s) due to larger sized raindrops in the 16 December case. LDR of raindrops in the 8 December case was less than 0.01, while it was 0.05-0.10 in the 16 December case. A possible reason for the LDR difference is discussed.