Computations are performed for a basic state with uniform static stability and for a three-layer basic state in which the two lowest layers represent the marine boundary layer and a strong capping inversion. One might suppose that the linear dynamics of disturbances in the three-layer basic state could be well approximated by a reduced-gravity shallow-water model, but this is not the case. In particular, the reduced-gravity shallow-water model does not provide reliable estimates for the phase speed of linear step-trapped Kelvin waves. This defect suggests that detailed quantitative comparisons between marine-boundary-layer flows and the reduced-gravity shallow-water system may not have any intrinsic physical significance. Nevertheless, these results do not preclude the possibility of constructing useful qualitative analogies between marine-boundary-layer flows and the reduced-gravity shallow-water model.