The ability of a scattering signal (observed brightness tempertaure colder than clear-sky brightness temperature by a threshold T) to detect snowfall (CloudSat reflectivity greater than threshold Z) is quantified using the Heidke Skill Score. The 183+/-1 and 183+/-3 GHz channels have the highest skill scores, while those channels that are sensitive to the surface (89, 150 and 183+/-7 GHz) have zero or even negative skill (depending on Z and T), implying that an emission signal (presumably from cloud water) is as good or better for detecting precipitation than a scattering signal. These results emphasize the need for proper characterization of surface emissivity and adequate representation of cloud water in cold season precipitation profiles that form the databases used for Bayesian retrievals from GMI and other GPM constellation radiometers.
Supplementary URL: