To best answer these questions, an analytical comparison was done for the Southern Plains' droughts of 2011 and 2012. To run the comparison, qualitative and quantitative approaches were taken. More specifically, a statistical comparison was completed by referencing the U.S. Palmer Drought Index, the Standardized Precipitation Index, and the Vegetation Drought Response Index. The latter was analyzed in conjunction with a variety of climatological and meteorological parameters, including temperature, soil moisture, evapotranspiration, precipitation, La Niña conditions, and the Arctic Oscillation. Finally, societal impacts were evaluated via the U.S. Drought Impact Reporter, state and county-wide official declarations of emergencies, and economical standings. Findings suggest that the most severe drought effects were present in 2011, with record maximum temperatures and a highly beleaguered crop and economical season. In addition, the shift in the Arctic Oscillation, early spring rains, and diminishing La Niña conditions can help account for the late onset of drought in 2012.